PhysicsHelp.co.uk

Testing a decay model with background counts

15 marks · A-level · original practice case

Write your working and explanations below or on paper. Your responses stay in this page; PhysicsHelp does not submit or save them. Copy anything you want to keep before closing it. Check calculations separately from method marks. Use unrounded working between parts.

The situation

A detector records counts for 60 s at each time after a short-lived source is prepared. Time is the midpoint of each counting interval. A separate background run gives 120 counts in 600 s. The simulated measurements are listed below. Treat the 60 s interval as short enough to represent the midpoint rate for this exercise; detector efficiency and geometry stay constant.

Simulated detector counts
Time / minCounts in 60 s
0972
2691
4492
6351
8253

Part (a)

Calculate the background-corrected count rate at 4 min. [2 marks]

Give the numerical answer to 3 significant figures.

Part (b)

Construct a graph to test exponential decay and obtain a half-life. Draw the graph on paper. [3 marks]

Part (c)

Determine the half-life from your graph. [3 marks]

Give the numerical answer to 3 significant figures. Graph readings between 3.8 and 4.2 min are accepted.

Part (d)

Evaluate the effect of failing to subtract background before making the logarithmic plot. [3 marks]

Part (e)

Suggest two changes that would strengthen the evidence for a single exponential decay. Explain each change. [4 marks]

Marking rubric and worked answers
One defensible graph and fitted lineWorked graph for review after attempting the construction. Numerical coordinates are listed in the marking guidance.. Horizontal axis: Time / min, 0 to 10. Vertical axis: ln(R / Rref), 0 to 3. Exact values are also listed below the graph.024681000.511.522.53Time / minln(R / Rref)
One example fit. Small differences in graph readings are expected; use the accepted range in the rubric.

Indicative practice marks. Method marks assess valid working; accuracy marks require the associated valid method. Independent points stand on their own. Tick only points supported by your response. Do not award the same explanation twice. These ticks record your judgement, not an examiner’s result.

Part (a) marking points

Final answer: 8.00 s⁻¹. Numerical checks assess the final value only; they do not check working or the number of digits typed.

No earlier numerical result is required. Credit a valid alternative method. Accuracy credit requires a physically valid method.

Part (b) marking points

Credit equivalent correct explanations. Award each distinct point once; a contradiction invalidates the affected point.

Acceptable alternatives: Plot ln(corrected counts / 1 count) against time, or use a base-10 logarithm with the corresponding half-life relation.

Part (c) marking points

Final answer: 4.00 min. Numerical checks assess the final value only; they do not check working or the number of digits typed.

Accept valid graph fits within the stated range. Credit a correctly applied logarithm/half-life relationship after a numerical gradient error. A negative half-life is not creditable.

Acceptable alternatives: For base-10 logs use T½ = log10(2)/magnitude of gradient.

Part (d) marking points

Credit equivalent correct explanations. Award each distinct point once; a contradiction invalidates the affected point.

Part (e) marking points

Credit equivalent correct explanations. Award each distinct point once; a contradiction invalidates the affected point.

Acceptable alternatives: Any two distinct justified changes earn up to two marks each. Do not award two versions of the same repetition suggestion.

Report a problem with this case

The case reference and selected part are attached. Only this report description is sent. Please leave out names, contact details and your practice answers.

Related skills

Scope and reference sources

AQA 3.8.1.3 and practical/mathematical skills; OCR A 6.4.3 and Modules 1/2. These are shared original exercises; wording, indicative marks and difficulty have not been endorsed by either board.

AQA specification · OCR A specification

Case reference: radioactive-background-fit · version 1.1.0 · seed 0. Choose another case